Which ring? Please help!?

Please help me! I'm proposing to my girlfriend and I've hit a wall with deciding which ring to buy. 

 

One ring is an aquamarine and two small diamond ring, in a design that closely matches a lot of her other jewlrey, making it an obvious choice for something she is likely to like. 

 

The second is a much more traditional ring, which I really like. It's diamonds diamonds diamonds, but it is unlike anything she currently owns. 

Logic tells me to get the aquamarine, since she obvisouly likes that style, but something in my head tells me I should get the flashier ring, since you only get one engagement ring, it should be something really special. 

What does everyone think? Simple and unassuming or big and flashy? Please help! 

Sign In or Register to comment.